Designing for Retention: Beyond the Initial User Experience
In the world of digital products, the initial user experience often gets the lion’s share of attention. The welcome screen, the onboarding flow, and the first few interactions are meticulously crafted to captivate users. But as data reveals, this focus might be misplaced. While the initial experience is crucial, long-term retention is what truly determines a product’s success.
The Retention Challenge
Consider these statistics: only about 25% of users return the day after their first interaction with a product, and by the end of the first month, retention levels plummet to around 6-7%. Even popular apps like Duolingo and Strava struggle to retain more than 20-25% of users after the first month. These numbers highlight a critical issue: despite well-crafted onboarding experiences, products often fail to become a lasting part of users’ routines.
This isn’t due to poor onboarding; rather, it underscores a fundamental design oversight. The effort required to attract users is vastly different from what’s needed to keep them engaged over the long term. Most products aren’t designed with this distinction in mind.
Retention is About Creating Gravity, Not Stickiness
There’s a common misconception that retention is about making products sticky. While reminders and streaks might bring users back temporarily, they rarely foster a genuine relationship with the product. True retention is about creating a gravitational pull—a natural inclination for users to return because the product seamlessly integrates into their lives.
For instance, tools like Notion and Asana don’t rely on nudges to retain users. Instead, they offer ongoing value by helping users stay organized and efficient. This continuous relevance builds a sense of gravity, making users want to return without feeling pressured.
Understanding the Context of Use
Designing for retention requires a deep understanding of the context in which users interact with your product. It’s not enough to make a product functional or delightful; it must fit into users’ lives. A product that aligns with users’ time, energy, and mindset is inherently more appealing than one that’s frictionless but out of sync.
Key Considerations for Contextual Design:
1. Timing: Are notifications arriving when they’re actually helpful, or are they just scheduled pushes? For instance, Coinbase allows users to receive price alerts for assets on their watchlist, ensuring notifications are timely and relevant.
2. Frequency: How often do users need the product? Acorns, for example, encourages users to set up recurring investments, allowing them to engage with the platform at appropriate intervals.
3. Mental State: Are users focused, stressed, or curious when they engage with your product? Calm, a meditation app, asks users to “take a deep breath” as soon as they open the app, catering to users who might be anxious or distracted.
4. Environment: Are users on the go, at a desk, or in bed? Uber addresses this by displaying ride updates on the lock screen, minimizing the effort required to check the app when users are in a hurry.
Designing with context means recognizing that different situations require different user flows. A budgeting app used weekly needs a different design approach than a journaling app opened spontaneously at night.
Shaping Users’ Habits
Many products attempt to create habit loops using the cue-action-reward model. However, if these loops serve only the product’s metrics and not the user’s goals, they fail. Instead, products should align with users’ underlying objectives, such as learning a skill or managing focus.
Designing Habit Loops with Users:
1. Start with the User’s Goal: Understand what users are working toward in the long term, not just the immediate task.
2. Design Cues That Respect Context: Notifications should feel timely and welcomed, not intrusive.
3. Keep Actions Doable: Simple, repeatable actions are more likely to become habits. For example, Pillow Talk, a journaling app, allows users to make entries through voice recordings, reducing the effort required to express themselves.
Designing for the Middle, Not Just the Start
Most design efforts focus on the initial user experience, but long-term value lies in what happens after the novelty wears off. For products centered around long-term goals—like personal finance, health, or education—the real test is maintaining user engagement over time.
Long-term UX Footprint > Dopamine Hits
Designing with continuity in mind ensures that a product remains relevant even after the initial excitement fades. Your goal as a designer is to create a user experience that holds up on day one hundred, not just day one.
In conclusion, while first impressions matter, the true measure of a product’s success is its ability to retain users. By designing with context and continuity in mind, products can become integral parts of users’ lives, ensuring sustained engagement and long-term success.
Leave a Reply